Best bathroom remodelers in Middletown
This ranking covers the ten highest-scoring bathroom remodelers serving Middletown, using our methodology that weighs Google ratings, review volume, recency, and sentiment together. It includes everyone from full-service design-build firms to tile specialists and handymen who take on bathroom work.
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to bathroom remodeler, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Re-Bath | 93 | 4.9 (271) | — | Full bathroom remodels, fast turnaround |
| 2 | New Bath Today | 91 | 4.8 (709) | — | Walk-in tub & aging-in-place conversions |
| 3 | Galleria Dream Kitchen and Bath | 82 | 4.9 (18) | — | Full design-build, older-home projects |
| 4 | New Creation Tile and Marble LLC | 78 | 4.9 (45) | — | Custom tile & shower work |
| 5 | Earthsake Initiatives | 78 | 5 (15) | — | Creative remodels with reclaimed materials |
| 6 | Handsome Handyman Services | 70 | 4.7 (13) | — | Small-to-midsize repairs and multi-trade fixes |
| 7 | Home Services at The Home Depot | 63 | 3 (2) | inexpensive | Big-box backed design consultation |
| 8 | Lombardo&Son Ceramic tile&marble LLC | 61 | 5 (3) | — | Tile specialist for small remodels |
| 9 | Dylan's Interior Painting | 60 | 5 (2) | — | Cosmetic touches: painting, ceilings, sink swaps |
| 10 | Majestic Renovations LLC | 30 | — | — | Newly listed, unproven option |
Ranked picks
Re-Bath
Why it ranks first
Re-Bath posts the highest composite score on this list, built on 271 reviews averaging 4.9 stars. Reviewers repeatedly name individual technicians (Josh, Devin, Carlos, Gallo) for precise work, and the team handles permits and trade coordination so homeowners aren't chasing plumbers and electricians themselves.
Pros
- Named, repeatedly praised technicians
- Jobs typically finish in one to four days
- Handles permits and coordinates other trades
- Crews clean up thoroughly each day
Services: walk in shower tub conversion, accessible aging in place, plumbing fixture installation, custom luxury bathroom design
New Bath Today
Why it ranks second
New Bath Today has the largest review base on this list (709 reviews, 4.8 stars), and most recent feedback centers on consultant Scott Destromp, who reviewers say listens carefully and never pushes a sale. It's a strong fit for shower conversions and accessibility upgrades planned around a set budget.
Pros
- Scott Destromp's pressure-free, patient consultations
- Strong focus on accessibility and aging-in-place design
- Budget-conscious approach to shower conversions
- Very high review volume backing the rating
Watch out: Recent reviews focus mostly on the consultation stage rather than finished installs.
Services: walk in shower tub conversion, accessible aging in place, plumbing fixture installation, custom luxury bathroom design
Galleria Dream Kitchen and Bath
Why it ranks third
Galleria Dream Kitchen and Bath keeps all trades in-house, so Jeffrey Stoyer's team handles design, 3D renderings, and installation without handing off to outside subcontractors. Reviewers credit project managers Ray and Anthony with careful adjustments in older homes where nothing lines up square.
Pros
- In-house design and trades, no subcontractor handoffs
- 3D rendering before work starts
- Custom cabinetry built and installed in-house
- Experience adapting to older home structural quirks
Watch out: Based on 18 reviews, so the track record is thinner than the top two entries.
Services: custom luxury bathroom design, full bathroom renovation, tile flooring work
New Creation Tile and Marble LLC
Why it ranks fourth
New Creation Tile and Marble earns consistent praise for grout and trim finishing on floors, backsplashes, and shower tile, with crews that clean up daily and typically finish on time. One recent cancellation with short notice and a dispute over undisclosed scope costs pulled the sentiment score down, so this is a case where the craftsmanship is strong but the paperwork needs care.
Pros
- Expert tile installation and finishing detail
- Punctual crews that clean the site daily
- Handles tricky leveling and custom layouts
- Responsive communication and design input
Watch out: Get full scope and pricing in writing; one client reported a last-minute cancellation and surprise added costs.
Services: tile flooring work, full bathroom renovation
Earthsake Initiatives
Why it ranks fifth
Owner Adam runs Earthsake Initiatives directly, and reviewers point to his responsiveness, honest cost estimates, and use of reclaimed and repurposed materials as what sets the work apart. A perfect 5.0 average across 15 reviews backs this up, though the sample is smaller than the top-ranked firms.
Pros
- Owner-led with a distinct artistic eye
- Creative use of reclaimed and repurposed materials
- Honest, upfront cost estimates
- Projects finished on time or early
Watch out: Only 15 reviews on record, so the sample size is modest.
Services: custom luxury bathroom design, full bathroom renovation
Handsome Handyman Services
Why it ranks sixth
Ben (BJ) at Handsome Handyman Services has built a run of five-star reviews over seven years for plumbing, tile, flooring, and drywall work, with reviewers citing fair pricing and speed. The review count is low and skews older, which is why the confidence here is lower than the firms above it.
Pros
- Diagnoses complex plumbing and electrical issues
- Works faster than typical handyman pace
- Fair, honest pricing
- Handles jobs from small repairs to full renovations
Watch out: Only 13 reviews, and several are dated, so recent performance is harder to confirm.
Services: plumbing fixture installation, full bathroom renovation, tile flooring work
Home Services at The Home Depot
Why it ranks seventh
Home Services at The Home Depot in Middletown has very limited recent review data: one older review praised designer Muriel's cabinet guidance, while a newer review flagged trouble reaching the location by phone. There isn't enough current feedback to judge the actual remodeling work.
Pros
- Backed by Home Depot's resources
- In-store design consultation available
Watch out: Only 2 reviews on file, and one cites phone access problems reaching the store.
Services: walk in shower tub conversion, full bathroom renovation, tile flooring work, plumbing fixture installation · Price: inexpensive
Lombardo&Son Ceramic tile&marble LLC
Why it ranks eighth
Joe Lombardo gets called out for master-level tile setting and clear, upfront cost breakdowns, with reviewers noting he shows up on time and answers questions patiently. The business has only 3 reviews on record, so this is a promising but thin sample.
Pros
- Master-level tile setting
- Clear cost breakdown before work starts
Watch out: Only 3 reviews available, so there's not much history to draw on.
Services: tile flooring work, full bathroom renovation
Dylan's Interior Painting
Why it ranks ninth
Dylan's Interior Painting lists bathroom sink replacement and tile work on its site, but the available reviews speak to interior painting and ceiling work rather than bathroom remodels specifically. With just 2 reviews, treat this as a lead worth a call rather than a proven bathroom specialist.
Pros
- Responsive scheduling
- Quality interior painting work
Watch out: No reviews currently speak to bathroom-specific work, despite it being listed as a service.
Services: full bathroom renovation, tile flooring work, plumbing fixture installation
Majestic Renovations LLC
Why it ranks tenth
Majestic Renovations LLC has a complete business profile listed for Middletown bathroom remodeling but zero reviews on record, so there's no track record yet to evaluate against the other firms on this list.
Pros
- Full business profile listed for the Middletown area
Watch out: No reviews yet, so there's no way to verify quality of work or reliability.
Services: full bathroom renovation, tile flooring work
How we scored this list
| Signal | Weight |
|---|---|
| Review sentiment | 28% |
| Google rating | 26% |
| Review volume | 20% |
| Profile completeness | 16% |
| Review recency | 10% |
Ranking data checked 2026-09-10 · Full methodology ›