Hall of Fame Construction Group vs KOHLER Store Greenwich: which fits your custom bathroom project?
The differences that matter
- Contractor vs showroom. Hall of Fame is a general contractor that demos and physically builds the bathroom, while the KOHLER Store is a fixture showroom and design consultation partner, not a construction crew.
- Single manager vs specialist pair. Matt personally manages every Hall of Fame job from start to finish, while KOHLER Store clients work with named product specialists Anna Makrides and Kimathi on fixture selection.
- Scope beyond the bathroom. Hall of Fame also handles roofing, siding, windows, and decking, useful if the bathroom remodel is part of a bigger renovation, while KOHLER Store's expertise stays focused on Kohler fixtures and design displays.
- How they fit into a project timeline. Hall of Fame drives the schedule itself and finishes work on time, while KOHLER Store is set up to slot into someone else's remodeling timeline and coordinate complex multi-bathroom orders.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Hall of Fame Construction Group LLC: 5 (54 reviews)
- KOHLER Store Greenwich by Plimpton & Hills: 4.9 (67 reviews)
- Services
- Hall of Fame Construction Group LLC: walk in shower tub conversion, custom luxury bathroom design, full bathroom renovation
- KOHLER Store Greenwich by Plimpton & Hills: tile flooring work, plumbing fixture installation, full bathroom renovation, custom luxury bathroom design
- Role in a custom bathroom project
- Hall of Fame Construction Group LLC: Does the actual demo, construction, and finish work
- KOHLER Store Greenwich by Plimpton & Hills: Supplies and specifies Kohler fixtures, no construction labor
- Best fit if you already hired a contractor
- Hall of Fame Construction Group LLC: Less useful, since Hall of Fame expects to run the whole job
- KOHLER Store Greenwich by Plimpton & Hills: Strong fit, built to coordinate with outside contractors and timelines
- Best fit for multi-bathroom or whole-house jobs
- Hall of Fame Construction Group LLC: Can bundle bathroom work with other trades like roofing and decking
- KOHLER Store Greenwich by Plimpton & Hills: Geared toward managing complex, multi-bathroom fixture orders
- Verification
- Hall of Fame Construction Group LLC: Google-verified
- KOHLER Store Greenwich by Plimpton & Hills: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Hall of Fame Construction Group LLC: 88
- KOHLER Store Greenwich by Plimpton & Hills: 88
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
Hall of Fame Construction Group LLC
Every review praises Matt and his crew for professionalism, honest work, and finishing on schedule. Customers repeatedly cite their reliability, fair pricing, and focus on doing the job right rather than cutting corners.
Hall of Fame handles roofing, siding, windows, and decking alongside kitchen and bathroom work. Matt personally manages projects and stays in close contact throughout. The team keeps sites clean and communicates clearly about costs before starting.
KOHLER Store Greenwich by Plimpton & Hills
Anna Makrides and Kimathi stand out for turning bathroom fixture selection into a stress-free collaboration. Reviewers consistently note their deep product knowledge, quick responses to emails and calls, and willingness to track down hard-to-find items within days. Prices hold their own against other Kohler dealers in the area.
The showroom itself offers hands-on design consultation with functioning displays. Contractors and homeowners alike return for multiple projects, citing the team's reliability in coordinating with remodeling timelines and managing complex, multi-bathroom orders without the high-pressure sales pitch.
Which should you pick?
Pick Hall of Fame Construction Group LLC if
- You want one crew that demos, builds, and finishes the bathroom itself, with Matt personally overseeing the job start to finish
- You're bundling the bathroom into a larger renovation that also touches roofing, siding, windows, or decking
- You want clear upfront pricing and a contract before work starts, with a track record of finishing on schedule
Pick KOHLER Store Greenwich by Plimpton & Hills if
- You already have a contractor or designer and need an expert to spec out Kohler fixtures for a custom bathroom
- You want to see and test fixtures on working displays in a showroom before committing to a luxury package
- You're outfitting multiple bathrooms and need someone who can source hard-to-find items fast and coordinate around a remodeling timeline
Verdict
The right pick depends on what part of the bathroom job you still need to cover. Choose Hall of Fame Construction Group if you need a crew to physically demo and rebuild the space, with Matt personally managing the work and pricing spelled out before anything starts. Choose KOHLER Store Greenwich if the construction side is already handled and you need expert help selecting, sourcing, and seeing luxury Kohler fixtures in a working showroom. Both post near-identical review scores, so the deciding factor is whether you need a builder or a fixture specialist, not which one rates higher.
Want help deciding which remodeler is right for you?
Describe your bathroom project once and get quotes from bathroom remodeler in Connecticut in your area.
Enquiries you submit may be shared with partner providers who can carry out the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores follow our published method only and are never influenced by referral fees.
Questions people ask
- Which one actually builds the bathroom?
- Hall of Fame Construction Group does the physical renovation work, from demo to finish, with Matt managing the crew. The KOHLER Store is a fixture showroom and design consultation stop, not a construction contractor.
- Which has the stronger review record?
- Hall of Fame sits at a 5.0 rating from 54 reviews with a composite score of 88. KOHLER Store Greenwich has a 4.9 rating from 67 reviews and a composite score of 87.6, so both are strong and effectively tied.
- Can I use both for one project?
- The data suggests it works well that way: KOHLER Store's summary notes contractors and homeowners return for multi-project fixture orders coordinated around remodeling timelines, which fits pairing it with a contractor like Hall of Fame.
- Which is better for sourcing hard-to-find luxury fixtures?
- That's a KOHLER Store strength per its review data: staff track down hard-to-find items on urgent timelines and offer functioning showroom displays for hands-on selection.