Atlantic Home Restoration vs Ventura Tile: which one for tile and flooring work?
Both of these Connecticut remodelers show up as strong picks for bathroom tile and flooring work, but they earn that reputation in different ways. This comparison uses our methodology to line up what the review data actually says about each one's tile craftsmanship, problem-solving, and aftercare track record.
The differences that matter
- Hidden problems vs standard install. Atlantic Home Restoration is repeatedly called out for catching structural issues like uneven walls or old construction defects before tiling over them, while Ventura Tile's praise centers on clean, competent execution of the tile job itself.
- Leak and waterproofing follow-through. Atlantic's summary highlights repairing leak-prone showers and tub surrounds as a core strength, whereas Ventura Tile has a documented complaint about a shower leak two months after install that the company declined to address.
- Track record size. Ventura Tile has 131 reviews against Atlantic's 53, giving it a much larger sample of completed jobs even though Atlantic's sentiment score (0.81) edges out Ventura's (0.70).
- Scope of work handled. Atlantic's pros list includes bathroom reconfiguration with wall removal and plumbing relocation, while Ventura's strengths lean toward fast, no-pressure tile jobs with named technicians.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Atlantic Home Restoration LLC: 5 (53 reviews)
- Ventura Tile: 4.9 (131 reviews)
- Services
- Atlantic Home Restoration LLC: full bathroom renovation, accessible aging in place, plumbing fixture installation, tile flooring work
- Ventura Tile: full bathroom renovation, walk in shower tub conversion, tile flooring work, custom luxury bathroom design
- Best for complex reconfiguration
- Atlantic Home Restoration LLC: Strong fit, handles wall removal and plumbing relocation alongside tiling
- Ventura Tile: Better for tile-focused jobs without structural changes
- Aftercare confidence for wet areas
- Atlantic Home Restoration LLC: Praised specifically for fixing leak-prone showers and tub surrounds
- Ventura Tile: One reported leak dispute post-install raises a caution flag for shower waterproofing
- Scheduling speed
- Atlantic Home Restoration LLC: Known for fast turnaround on tight deadlines and same-day consultations
- Ventura Tile: Known for same-day response and quick project completion
- Verification
- Atlantic Home Restoration LLC: Google-verified
- Ventura Tile: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Atlantic Home Restoration LLC: 88
- Ventura Tile: 88
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
Atlantic Home Restoration LLC
Alex and his team consistently deliver high-quality bathroom and tile work with meticulous attention to detail. Reviewers praise their professionalism, ability to meet tight timelines, and commitment to keeping the job site clean throughout. They excel at identifying structural issues (like uneven walls or original construction problems) and solving them without cutting corners, building lasting client relationships.
Ventura Tile
Ventura Tile earns strong trust through fast response times, fair pricing, and thorough cleanup; technicians like Davison and Deivi are named repeatedly for professionalism and technical know-how. One household reported a shower leak two months post-install that the company refused to address, a significant caveat against relying on their aftercare guarantees.
Which should you pick?
Pick Atlantic Home Restoration LLC if
- Your bathroom has uneven walls, old construction issues, or other structural surprises you want caught before tiling
- The job involves reconfiguring the space (wall removal, moving plumbing) alongside tile and flooring
- You've had leak problems in a shower or tub surround and want someone who specializes in fixing that root cause
Pick Ventura Tile if
- You want a contractor with a large, established review history (131 reviews) to check against
- You need same-day response and a quick, no-pressure tile installation without added structural work
- You want named technicians (Davison, Deivi) with a specific track record you can ask for by name
Verdict
The right pick depends on whether your tile job is a straightforward installation or comes with structural unknowns. Atlantic Home Restoration LLC fits jobs where hidden issues (uneven framing, leak-prone showers, reconfigured layouts) are likely, since diagnosing and fixing those problems before tiling is central to its praise. Ventura Tile fits simpler, faster tile jobs backed by a much larger review base, though its one documented unresolved leak complaint is worth weighing if your project involves wet-area waterproofing.
Want help deciding which remodeler is right for you?
Describe your bathroom project once and get quotes from bathroom remodeler in Connecticut in your area.
Enquiries you submit may be shared with partner providers who can carry out the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores follow our published method only and are never influenced by referral fees.
Questions people ask
- Which business has more review volume for tile and flooring work?
- Ventura Tile has 131 Google reviews compared to Atlantic Home Restoration's 53, giving it a larger track record to evaluate.
- Which one is better if my bathroom has structural issues under the tile?
- Atlantic Home Restoration is specifically praised for identifying construction defects like uneven walls and fixing them rather than tiling over them.
- Is there any concern about leaks after installation?
- Ventura Tile has one reported case of a shower leak two months after install that the company reportedly didn't address, which is worth asking about directly if you choose them.